What's new
Christian Community Forum

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate fully in the fellowship here, including adding your own topics and posts, as well as connecting with other members through your own private inbox!

Escalate or concede defeat? US faces dilemma over Houthis in Yemen

Excerpts from article:

Only the Houthis, once dismissed as a barely relevant sideshow, remain fully engaged, with high capacities, and determined to continue the fight. They are the only Iran-aligned force not to have suffered serious setbacks since launching their campaign. They are also the sole member of the pro-Iran axis to have directed its attacks not at Israel alone but also at Western targets.

It has been a year since a US-flagged ship has passed through the Suez Canal. The Trump administration, contrary to its preference for deals to end acts of aggression elsewhere, appears determined to force the Houthis to end their campaign, and appears willing to back up threats with force. At the commencement of the offensive in March, Trump warned the Yemeni Shia Islamists that if the attacks on shipping did not stop, “hell will rain down upon you like nothing you have ever seen before.”

The US are uneasy over the Houthis' growing influence

US concerns regarding the Houthis go beyond the immediate Yemeni context. Over the last six months, evidence has emerged of a growing connection between Ansar Allah and the al-Shabaab organization in Somalia. A February UN report noted that personnel of the two movements met in Somalia in July and September 2024.

Here, the US faces a dilemma similar to that which Israel faced vis-à-vis Hamas in Gaza. In both cases, the Islamist enemy is largely indifferent to losses of life among its own people, and unlikely to even be inclined to change direction as a result of losses among its own personnel or of its own equipment.

At this point, the US faces options regarding the Houthis similar to those that Israel faced regarding Gaza – namely, escalate or effectively concede. Either a decision must be taken to destroy or severely degrade the enemy, or it must be accepted that the Houthis, while they can be engaged in a tit-for-tat exchange of fire in which they pay the higher cost, cannot at present be defeated.

It is against this background that the recent reports of a possible ground offensive against the Houthis by Yemeni government and allied troops should be understood.

Complete Article

 
Related

US struggling to contain Yemen as Houthis down MQ-9 drones - report​


The US military's ongoing campaign against the Houthi rebel group in Yemen, launched on March 15, has encountered significant setbacks, primarily due to the loss of American drones, which have hindered key surveillance operations, CNN reported on Friday, citing US officials familiar with the situation.

US officials had initially hoped to establish air superiority over Yemen within 30 days of launching the campaign, setting the stage for a shift to "phase two," which would involve more aggressive surveillance and targeting of Houthi leadership, the report noted.

However, reports of repeated destruction of MQ-9 Reaper drones, used for gathering intelligence and conducting surveillance, have delayed those plans.

“We are aware of the Houthi reports that these MQ-9s have been shot down,” a US defense official told CNN. “While hostile fire is likely a probable cause, the circumstances of each incident are still under investigation.”

Without boots on the ground in Yemen, the US military heavily depends on drones for surveillance, battlefield damage assessments, and tracking Houthi activities, officials said.

More

 
Could this be a case of once again our war fighters are being held back by politicians? Donald Trump seems to be determined to keep his reputation of never having started a war. So, our military is being tasked with taking on an enemy but only insofar as it can be done solely from the air. As a result we're spending a lot of money with very few results. And we are looking weak and the Houthis are looking stronger. How about we take the leashes off and allow our war fighters to do whatever they need to do to accomplish the task they have been given. What do our military members here think?
 
There is only so much that can be accomplished from the air. While the US has blown up a lot of stuff and killed some Houthis, there has been no meaningful accomplishment and the problem that the Houthis pose to the world has not been diminished.
 
Back
Top