What's new
Christian Community Forum

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate fully in the fellowship here, including adding your own topics and posts, as well as connecting with other members through your own private inbox!

A Psalm 83 War: Defense by Bill Salus

1LoverofGod

Well-known
Is Psalm 83 a prophecy about an end time war between Israel and its neighbors, or is it something else?

In the previous segment, Dr. Tommy Ice, who is the Director of the Pre-Trib Research Center, listed his objections against Psalm 83 being about a future war. In this segment, Bill Salus of Prophecy Depot Ministries, who wrote the Psalm 83-themed book Isralestine, will respond to Dr. Ice and state his reasons for why he believes Psalm 83 is indeed prophetic.

First of all, I highly recommend Tommy Ice who is an excellent teacher when it comes to talking about the Pre-Trib Rapture. Often I will refer people to the Pre-Trib Rapture website. I think that he has done a lot of outstanding work on it.

I do also agree with him that Psalm 83 is a prayer of lament, also called an imprecatory prayer. Asaph is calling upon the Lord to intervene and he is beseeching God to deal with His adversaries.

Read More

 
Great read, thanks for posting it.

Salus in this article, and in his book, makes a strong case why he believes its a war. I lean towards that Psalm describing an actual war, and one that could soon break out with the current fighting in the middle east.
I posted this on another thread:

I found this overview (from TCC on JDF):

Psalm 83 lists the following countries:

  • Lebanon
  • Syria
  • Jordan
  • Iraq
  • Palestine
  • Egypt
  • Saudi Arabia
Isreali Friendly Nations Right Now Are the Following:

  • Jordan
  • Egypt
  • Saudi Arabia
Therefore, in order for what we see happening today to be the Psalm 83 war, Jordan, Egypt, and Saudi-Arabia will have to turn against Israel. This is highly unlikely.

Iran was not included in Psalm 83. Yet, Iran is THE MAJOR agressor today. Therefore, this does not look like the Psalm 83 war.

Edit to add:
@TCC, your lists. I borrowed them, like I told you.
Btw, so happy you joined. Love you dear brother!
 
I posted this on another thread:

I found this overview (from TCC on JDF):

Psalm 83 lists the following countries:

  • Lebanon
  • Syria
  • Jordan
  • Iraq
  • Palestine
  • Egypt
  • Saudi Arabia
Isreali Friendly Nations Right Now Are the Following:

  • Jordan
  • Egypt
  • Saudi Arabia
Therefore, in order for what we see happening today to be the Psalm 83 war, Jordan, Egypt, and Saudi-Arabia will have to turn against Israel. This is highly unlikely.

Iran was not included in Psalm 83. Yet, Iran is THE MAJOR agressor today. Therefore, this does not look like the Psalm 83 war.
At least not yet…..

Iran is not yet overtly directly involved militarily but no doubt is funding Hamas, and of course Hezbollah.

Iran is waiting for the next war….Ezekiel 38.

Your friendly nations lists is not updated. All of those listed have come out against Israel
 
I posted this on another thread:

I found this overview (from TCC on JDF):

Psalm 83 lists the following countries:

  • Lebanon
  • Syria
  • Jordan
  • Iraq
  • Palestine
  • Egypt
  • Saudi Arabia
Isreali Friendly Nations Right Now Are the Following:

  • Jordan
  • Egypt
  • Saudi Arabia
Therefore, in order for what we see happening today to be the Psalm 83 war, Jordan, Egypt, and Saudi-Arabia will have to turn against Israel. This is highly unlikely.

Iran was not included in Psalm 83. Yet, Iran is THE MAJOR agressor today. Therefore, this does not look like the Psalm 83 war.

Edit to add:
@TCC, your lists. I borrowed them, like I told you.
Btw, so happy you joined. Love you dear brother!
Like I said before, Im not positive one way or the other on this being a war. If it is, we will know sooner rather than later.

Good info posted between the back and forth of Salus and Dr Ice.

I also side with Arnold Fruchtenbaum.
 
I've considered the idea that Psalm 83 is a possible prophecy -- and the position of some that it was fulfilled in the several wars of Israel for it's survival, as an ongoing fulfillment.

But

I think that several other passages may fit the current situation better than Psalm 83 as it was originally written by Bill Salus. I like his writing, I like his thinking, I like his take on things.

However Bill has ALSO written a book on Elam that got me going on that idea and it fits a bit better if you consider that there is a lot of overlap between 3 passages-- 2 of which mention Elam plus Damascus and Syria, and 1 which mentions Damascus. And it was Bill that got me over the hurdle with Jer 49:28-33 in which he explained that bit was a past fulfillment while the others are yet future.

I refer to

Isaiah 17
Jeremiah 49
with the exception of v 28-33 which refer to a past fulfillment with Babylon.
Ezekiel 32:17-32


Why I don't think this is Ps 83
I posted this on another thread:

I found this overview (from TCC on JDF):

Psalm 83 lists the following countries:

  • Lebanon
  • Syria
  • Jordan
  • Iraq
  • Palestine
  • Egypt
  • Saudi Arabia
Isreali Friendly Nations Right Now Are the Following:

  • Jordan
  • Egypt
  • Saudi Arabia
Therefore, in order for what we see happening today to be the Psalm 83 war, Jordan, Egypt, and Saudi-Arabia will have to turn against Israel. This is highly unlikely.

Iran was not included in Psalm 83. Yet, Iran is THE MAJOR agressor today. Therefore, this does not look like the Psalm 83 war.

Edit to add:
@TCC, your lists. I borrowed them, like I told you.
Btw, so happy you joined. Love you dear brother!

Thanks to Erika and TCC for that nice tidy list.

So what about Jordan, Egypt and Saudi Arabia? AND IRAN isn't mentioned in Psalm 83 but it is the current driving force behind this war Oct 7, 2023

We NEED TO LOOK AT IRAN


Jordan and Egypt actually fit really well in the current situation if you read Ezek 32:17-32 where Egypt makes its appearance along with Syria & Iraq(Assyria) plus southern Jordan (Edom) along with Lebanon, Turkey, Iran (Elam)and the "Princes of the North". The common theme is terrorism which is "spread among the land of the living"-- this is a broader scope of terror than just Israel being wiped out.

Never forget that Islam wants to eliminate Jews, first in Israel and around the world, then Christians. They are frequently quoted as saying they want to kill all the Saturday people first, then come after the Sunday people as they put it. Certainly Iran's focus isn't just Israel but it begins there and the attack on Israel using their proxy Hamas on October 7, 2023


In Jeremiah 49 Jordan appears as Ammon and Edom -the north and south of Jordan with Damascus and Elam (south west Iran) again. And here's where Damascus comes in. This is the parallel passage to Isaiah 17 which is all about Damascus. (Syria and parts of Iraq are in Ezek 32 as Assyria, and Damascus appears here and in Isaiah 17)


Bill makes an excellent case for "the Tents of Edom" being a possible likely reference to the Palestinians of the West Bank and Gaza. Gazans are also partly Egyption in origin. That applies whether he is teaching on Psalm 83 or on these 3 passages. Obadiah is another important reference-- Day of the Lord AND Edom but I want to just concentrate on these big 3.


That leaves Saudi Arabia (Sheba and Dedan) who appear in Ezek 38. They are the nearest that Israel has to an ally along with the merchants of Tarshish and cubs. IF (big IF there) IF Ezek 38 is in the somewhat near future (I see it as coming after the Damascus/Elam war and just after the Rapture at some point) then we shouldn't see too much from the Saudis although activity on the Abe Accords are on hold for now since the invasion of Israel.

The Saudis have been actively working with Israel on several projects including a rail line terminating on Israel's sea coast in the Med to bring oil to Euro markets without the fear of terrorism by Iran or problems with the Suez Canal. This is why China opposes Israel in this current conflict because Israel is in direct competition with China for a similar trade route-- the new Silk Road/Belt thing they are working on.

The fact that the Saudis, Egypt and Jordan are not active enemies of Israel is important even if they pay lip service to their Islamic populations by denouncing Israel.



So who is involved?

Well everyone except Saudi Arabia from the Psalm 83 list AND ALSO IRAN and Turkey plus "the princes of the North". -- And THOSE (Saudi Arabia, IRAN, Turkey and Russia) make different appearances in Ezek 38 which I think comes AFTER the war as outlined in Isaiah 17, Jeremiah 49 and Ezekiel 32:17-32



WHY?

Terrorism-- spread by Iran. Ez 32:17-32 In this passage Egypt is the key-- she and her allies die due to terrorism spread in the land of the living while Iran as Elam (south west Iran) is singled out for special mention as spreading terror. Jordan's capitol city Amman in the north is involved as "the children of Ammon" as well as Edom in the south. Turkey apparently doesn't have time to draw her weapons, and her army dies without landing a blow. Lebanon is here as Sidonians and then there is the odd mention of the "Princes of the North". Since we already have Syria, Lebanon and Turkey, who are all "north" of Israel in some fashion, Russia is really the best fit here.

All of these countries have been involved in some way or another-- with Egypt and Jordan playing a more minor role lately.

Jeremiah 49 -- Driving out Israel and stealing the land (Amman Jordan motive), Terrorism (Edom's motive) and Elam's motive in Ezek 32 is terrorism, while her method in Jer 49 seems to be using some type of missile launchers--their bows, the strength of their might aimed at Israel as the passage infers (Bill goes into this in depth).

Isaiah 17:14b Loot and plunder appear to be Damascus's motives but crossed with Jeremiah 49 a fuller picture appears. Jerusalem may have been the object of theft-- but Damascus disappears as a result (Is 17 v 9) of something that Damascus Syria starts --and the IDF finishes (children of Israel) I think considering Syria's past with Israel they will try to go in to try and take Israeli land again. The area of northern Israel (Golan Heights) above the sea of Galilee is particularly vulnerable. If Syria figures Russia will help, they may well attack. Russia has SAID the Golan is Syria's because Russia wants to exploit it.



How long does it take?
It may go in stages-- BUT Isaiah 17 says the Damascus part of it is overnight. Ezek 32:26 says that Turkey doesn't seem to have had time or ability to get their weapons on before death overtakes them. So it may be a very fast response.

There's an interesting reference in Jer 49:23 of the 2 northern provinces of Syria between Damascus and the border with Turkey. Hamath and Arpad are Hama and Aleppo. If there was a sudden small nuclear explosion or other such catastrophe in that area it would knock out some of southern Turkey.



So what are the differences between Ps 83 and this outline above? Why nit pick?

Because Ps 83 is just about removing Israel from being a nation, and it includes 3 nations that are more or less working with Israel most times in spite of rhetoric.

Psalm 83 DOESN'T include IRAN, or Turkey, or Russia for that matter and they play a role in the current conflict and are mentioned in at least one of the 3 passages I cite.

My scenario above using Isaiah 17, Jeremiah 49 and Ezekiel 32:17-32 includes Iran, Turkey and Russia and gives more nuanced reasons for why the different groups are doing what they do.

IT also lays the groundwork for why Russia, Turkey and Iran along with a few others invade Israel in Ezek 38 later on. To recoup their losses and settle their grievances. Ezek 38 specifies spoil as a main motive but not the only one.
 
At least not yet…..

Iran is not yet overtly directly involved militarily but no doubt is funding Hamas, and of course Hezbollah.

Iran is waiting for the next war….Ezekiel 38.

Your friendly nations lists is not updated. All of those listed have come out against Israel
I understand how it looks in print. But I believe thoug having socio-political and economic ties with Israel supercedes moods. Jordan, for example, has peace treaty and some interest in common projects/trade. As well and Egypt. i would not sense to update Israeli friendly status based on newspaper version positions due to politcal tensions within Jordanian and Egyptian countries. Samples why.

j O R D O N
According to oec.world JORDAN
Jordan-Israel In 2021, Jordan exported $343M to Israel. The main products that Jordan exported to Israel are Video Displays ($77.4M), Ethylene Polymers ($64.4M), and Sodium or Potassium Peroxides ($28.7M). During the last 26 years the exports of Jordan to Israel have increased at an annualized rate of 22.2%, from $1.86M in 1995 to $343M in 2021.


E G Y P T

EXCERPTS FROM ARTICLE
But Egypt also has an evolving relationship with Israel, starting with the Camp David Accords, signed by US President Jimmy Carter, Egyptian President Anwar Sadat, and Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin in 1978. That relationship has grown from a framework for peace talks to economic and security cooperation that’s important to both sides. Specifically, Israel helps Egypt fight Islamic extremists on the Sinai peninsula and imports natural gas into Egypt, which puts pressure on the Egyptians not to upset that relationship.

“The question is, will [the Egyptian government] suffer more from helping or not helping? The goal would be to be seen as helping, but not do much from the Egyptian point of view,” said Byman.

Blessings.
 
I just finished reading a Daymond Duck article and it was saying that Hamas purpose wasn't for retaliation of perceived "Palestinian injustice" but to rather expand the war fronts in the hopes that Iran and Hezbollah would jump in on the war.

So far it's been a fail for them
 
The fact that the Saudis, Egypt and Jordan are not active enemies of Israel is important even if they pay lip service to their Islamic populations by denouncing Israel.



So who is involved?

Well everyone except Saudi Arabia from the Psalm 83 list AND ALSO IRAN and Turkey plus "the princes of the North". -- And THOSE (Saudi Arabia, IRAN, Turkey and Russia) make different appearances in Ezek 38 which I think comes AFTER the war as outlined in Isaiah 17, Jeremiah 49 and Ezekiel 32:17-32
Amen Margery to the first quote. I took a long look today at Ez 32. What mystery there is regarding Egypt in that first half is in 605 Babylon only severly hurt Egypt in one battle...but Egypt survived rather well after...seemingly doing better than latter Babylon. Unless some of this is fulfilled by Babylon the Great in the tribulation, I have not really seen this addressed anywhere though. As the second half of Ez 32, it seems like the most common theme is this is a metaphoric dirge. Like those who meet Egypt in the grave. Also themed as a lamentation (similar in what is done in Ezekiel with Tyre). Albeit these kinds of prophetic language do take time to parce out amen.

I'm of the school of thought that perhaps Damascus is a prophecy is heavy language "hyperbole" as seemingly Egypt was handled in Ez 32. But I would be open for a future Damascus prophecy perhaps. My sense in general is that i see the thematics of globalism most apply to the beast system moving forward rather to global movements in countries to try and hold on for survival. I don't see a one world system formed out of the current NWO. But rather a reemergeence in seal 3. We prophecy heads do have different views...lol...don't we :)

In general, I'd see things heat up globally in reference to the American election. In part perhaps that America kind of sees a lot being about our country (i guess of "local" bias of sorts). But being that globlaims is currently raiding the American treasury, it would stand to some measure of reason that America has much to do with what direction and control globalism can have. Catherine Austine Fitts used to be among them, and sees many factions and they are not as gathered as we might think. i belelieve there is a pretty good chance that they have huge weak spots and are genuinely threatened by America 2024 election. With Hamas support being the new BLM/Antifa rioters for 2024. So i would see some activity into the new year concerning that. But in the general short term I would likely slate the Israeli conflicts to dove tail into a firmer grip of the Abraham Accords and peace in the region ironically. But likely not without a baptism by fire of sorts.

Thanks for sharing your heart. Some interesting point to consider. You had my nose in the book today. Blessings dear sister. :)
 
I just finished reading a Daymond Duck article and it was saying that Hamas purpose wasn't for retaliation of perceived "Palestinian injustice" but to rather expand the war fronts in the hopes that Iran and Hezbollah would jump in on the war.

So far it's been a fail for them

The timing too of the desire for Saudi Arabia to normalize with Israel seems to be a potential reason too. There is the belief out there that several groups related to Iranian coordination would have been planning a multi-front attack on Israel, and Hamas jumped the gun. This seems plausable. But i would get the sense that how factions work are not necessarily as clean cut as we might at times surmise. There are coordinated efforts, and there are divergent group desires and focus. Sometimes they work well together. And sometimes they don't. There is a randomness to it i believe.

However, overall, the way i would look at Hamas is the following = I do subscribe to the school of thought that Iran had been forming a multi-front attack that would have been much much more severe in that not to distant future (like a miniature golf version of Ez 38). And Hamas did jump the gun. But i believe the reason may not be something Hamas did on their own. It would seem to also be a multi-factored teaming involvement with some elite globalist factions who would have need of Hamas activity "now" not later because of the Saudi normalization and the coming US election cycle. Both are threats to globalism as far as i can tell.

So in that sense, it would seem that from the grander picture, yes Hamas jumped the gun. But jumped the gun perhaps with cause based on the desires of other mitigating factions who needed them more now than later. In any event, the darkness and ingorance of thee wicked will tend to drive them to make conclusions that don't factor in enough when they act. So it would seem that as gross as this attack was, it seems to be to some degree in line with God perhaps limiting worse via forcing the haters to reveal their hand much earlier than they (in their dark arts of planning might have liked to have been so exposed. And in and out of tjos sense of desperation, run with using Hamas to ramp up and soup up bad vibes for the next several months hoping for momentum and escalating tensions against Saudi Arabia and America simultanously. if Saudi Arabia normalizes, others will follow, and that would give Israel too much credibility in the eyes of the Middle East block haters. If that makes sense? Blessings.
 
Thanks Kaatje. I am very blessed something i posted can contribute to discussion to any degree. I got that list from another JDF forum members video production. So it helped me to see too some very simple ways to look at differences. Bless you sister for your huge heart in Christ. I am encourage that list could be helpful to how it might be. I believe it does. Blessings.

General Forum FYI -- My escatology is:

  • Literal 1,000 Reign of Christ on Earth
  • Pre-millenial tribulation (7 years)
  • Pre-trib rapture

I do have some views that are not as conventional in mainstream watcher communities. But i am very interested to learn from the conventional view types. In general i believe we are in a rapture time zone (or rapidly approaching). I would have some subtle to mild, to some significant differences as relates to generall watcher trajectories/scenarios for how escatology plays out between now and the tribulation. I just mention that to be helpful just in that my differing views from Psalm 83 or my sense of Ezekiel 38 timing may be somewhat different than the general blueprint per mainstream watcher community perspectives. There are "a lot" of similarities but definately some significant differences. I think that might be generally helpful to know in light of some ways i might make mention along the way that may not seem to track holistically with some mainstream views in play today. I am always open to correction and/or adjusting my views where the Lord may provide. But its helpful i believe in some ways to highlight i kind of come in different packaging if you will...lol.

My views, for example, in relation to Psalm 83 do have an "a-typical" component of seeing it more a prayer than prophecy (however I'm certainly open to consider other wise--up to and including the potential of a real time unfolding of such a war today). But the main reason my potentially non-conventional aspect view would differ than an oncoming Psalm like 83 war is that i would see Saudi Arabia and the Abraham Accords playing a much louder role potentially in near term prophetic directions. I only know of one other person that sees similar (that Abraham Accords play in big potentially with prophecy and would appear even these days to have the upper hand), but we would equally hold that conviction yet from extremely different escatological reasons. As an example.

In any event...thanks Kaatje again for the invite and warm warm welcome along with cheerful a gentle heart in him. Blessings.
 
Thanks for the kind words, @TCC.

I know that sometimes we agree to disagree on some topics, but that makes no difference to you being my dear brother in Christ. All our differences will be ironed out when we get to see one and other on the other side of the clouds, together with all that are covered by the blood of Christ, our Saviour.

Looking forward to that day, when all will be explained and maybe we all will be astonished about how beautiful Gods plans were accomplished.

(On the topic of Psalms 83, we very much agree though 😉)
 
On Psalm 83, I've kind of gone from thinking it was a possible future event, to a past event fulfilled in either OT times and/or the Arab/Israeli wars, to currently being in the imprecatory prayer camp. If nothing else, it just reads that way. One of those positions is undoubtedly right ...🤣

I guess we'll see, but the more I think about it, the more I find Andy Woods' unconventional timing for Ezekiel 38 plausible. I do like his tongue in check conjecture that the half hour silence in Heaven is when everyone adjusts their prophecy charts.
 
On Psalm 83, I've kind of gone from thinking it was a possible future event, to a past event fulfilled in either OT times and/or the Arab/Israeli wars, to currently being in the imprecatory prayer camp. If nothing else, it just reads that way. One of those positions is undoubtedly right ...🤣

I guess we'll see, but the more I think about it, the more I find Andy Woods' unconventional timing for Ezekiel 38 plausible. I do like his tongue in check conjecture that the half hour silence in Heaven is when everyone adjusts their prophecy charts.
His Ez 38 timing is definitely an interesting take on when it would happen and one i haven't heard before.
 
On Psalm 83, I've kind of gone from thinking it was a possible future event, to a past event fulfilled in either OT times and/or the Arab/Israeli wars, to currently being in the imprecatory prayer camp. If nothing else, it just reads that way. One of those positions is undoubtedly right ...🤣

I guess we'll see, but the more I think about it, the more I find Andy Woods' unconventional timing for Ezekiel 38 plausible. I do like his tongue in check conjecture that the half hour silence in Heaven is when everyone adjusts their prophecy charts.
I had not heard any other end times teacher mention what Woods believes. The more I consider something I never considered before, what would stop Israel from having to burn the weapons and bury the bodies during the first years of the Millennium?

I always thought the most likely scenario is EZ 38 taking place after the rapture, and being over before the tribulation starts. But, who knows but Him. It would however, be nice to still be here and watch God destroy the attacking coalition.
 
On Psalm 83, I've kind of gone from thinking it was a possible future event, to a past event fulfilled in either OT times and/or the Arab/Israeli wars, to currently being in the imprecatory prayer camp. If nothing else, it just reads that way. One of those positions is undoubtedly right ...🤣

I guess we'll see, but the more I think about it, the more I find Andy Woods' unconventional timing for Ezekiel 38 plausible. I do like his tongue in check conjecture that the half hour silence in Heaven is when everyone adjusts their prophecy charts.

Thanks for your post Greg. I was reformed for a number of years. But have appreciated Andy Woods teaching a lot in the past few years. From what I understand, Woods sees Ez 38 and 39 as two separate wars. Ez 38 at the beginning of the trib and Ez 39 at Armegeddon. I have come to share his view on Ez 38 as seal 2 potential. However, i would lean toward Ez 39 as the same war. Yet he does make some good points about it being later. Blessings.
 
Back
Top