So any statement in the scriptures of Satan and the Beast and the false prophet being tormented I understand has to be symbolic of total annihilation. The lake if fire isn't said to be a literal lake of fire but is symbolic or represents the second death. Death is a condition not a place or person or object, this includes the second death. The second death is a permanent condition, and that permanent condition is eternal death.
Clearly that is your conclusion drawn from your own interpretation. And just as clearly you are not going to be convinced otherwise. And that is your right. In a direct sense this is not a salvation issue, so we can disagree on the issue and still maintain fellowship.
That said, a lot of people visit this site, both saved and unsaved, both biblically literate and illiterate and somewhere in-between. Therefore, for the sake of the unlearned and the unsaved we cannot allow heterodox doctrine to stand on the open board lest it lead someone into error. God forbid that we would ever be the cause of this. I hope you understand that this is why this thread will be removed once members have had a chance to read to the end.
Now why would I say that if this is not a salvation issue? Because even though it is not directly soteriological, it may be so tangentially. You see, if I am a hedonist and enjoying the pleasures of the flesh and seeing no need for God, the idea that after death I will not suffer torment but will simply go off into non-existence does not sound such a bad thing. After all I will have had however many years of pure pleasure and self-satisfaction here obtaining as much as I desire to enjoy. And when death comes, so what? There are no real consequences for my actions or my rejection of God. I will simply cease to exist.
Now, by teaching annihilism you are actually giving that message ... in direct contradiction to God's abundant warnings of judgment and punishment. There are more warnings of punishment, its severity and length, in Scripture than descriptions of heaven. God must have had a reason to warn us so severely. Further Jesus spoke of degrees of punishment. How can there be different levels of punishment if the punishment is simply annihilation?
Now, I happen to agree with you that the lake of fire is likely not a literal lake of fire and also that the pit where the worm does not die nor the flame is quenched (Mark 9:24) is allegorical. BUT!!! That does not mean that something as terrible does not exist. God is trying to warn us of something so horrible, so fearful that an undying, unquenchable, unending flame is the closest thing on earth He could compare it to. He even compares it to burning sulphur. If you recall anything from high school chemistry class, you'll remember that sulphur sticks to anything it touches when it burns and cannot be dislodged. It is like napalm that clings and cannot be smothered or extinguished. It can be smothered with a blanket but will still burn; it can be submerged under water and still agonizingly consume what it has fastened to. What a terrible way to die on this earth!!! And that is the picture God is trying to give us humans about the fate of those who reject His Son.
Yet you, and other anihilationists, teach people to basically not worry about this. It's not so bad. You'll just cease to exist. Which, though it might not be your intention, actually works to negate the picture that God is trying place into our minds of the fate awaiting those who choose their way rather than His.
Yes, the Lake of Fire may not be literal since the life after this one will be on an unending, unchanging spiritual plane rather than a temporal, decaying plane such as this one. Therefore descriptions of something beyond our ability to comprehend (let alone conceive) must of necessity be allegorical. But the allegory will as accurately as possible convey the reality of the actual. Far be it from God to exaggerate to make a point. No, the Creator will tell it as accurately as it is. And He has. He has described a fate for those who reject Him as one of endless torment. We can take Him at His Word. So, in no way will this board be party to attempting to blunt or lighten any warning of God, because His warnings are not given for effect. They are very, very, VERY real.
This thread is now closed. If anybody wishes to continue this discussion with me, please use the private message system.