What's new
Christian Community Forum

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate fully in the fellowship here, including adding your own topics and posts, as well as connecting with other members through your own private inbox!

Excellent updated analysis of DC/helo crash, including NTSB report from 14 Feb

The below link include analysis from host web site, and details released yesterday by the NTSB. Good minute by minute actions of both aircraft as reported in this latest update from NTSB.

19 min video

@Tall Timbers

For decades its been noticed in America how generally bad training is at businesses. Not in every case. But there has seemed to have been quite a history in America of companies "in general" offering bad training as a rule. And unfortunately when it comes to this sector, people die as a result. Sad. Thanks for sharing brother. Blessings.
 
The below link include analysis from host web site, and details released yesterday by the NTSB. Good minute by minute actions of both aircraft as reported in this latest update from NTSB.

19 min video

@Tall Timbers


I don't have 19 minutes to give to the video but I've read a couple articles that say that those in the helicopter cockpit didn't receive critical info from the tower. The flight recorder caught the first part and then there was not finish to the statement from the tower.
 
Heartbreaking! Hopefully lessons are learned, and taken to heart. I found the comments under that video that @Andy C posted, very informative. A combination of errors, which normally wouldn't result in an accident, but the errors piled up on each other.

Here's what I got from the video:

Night vision goggles, poor peripheral vision in the helicopter, at night with ambient glare. (other vids with Army training heli pilots mention that 4 people in the cockpit for a training flight is best practice- with 2 people checking the sides of the helicopter while the student and trainer work.)

An Air Traffic Controller understaffed, doing 2 jobs at once. Managing the helicopter and the airplane coming in to land.

An allowed margin of 100 feet clearance which is less than the allowable margin for error in a properly functioning altimeter. That horrified a lot of pilots in the comments.

Last minute runway change.

George used to watch Mentour Pilot who often does a post mortem on these accidents, but he takes his time and waits till all the info is in, and when he can devote time to that video so hes' usually 6 months later. He is a working airlines pilot based in Spain or Portugal. He always mentions the swiss cheese model for accidents, which is that the holes all have to line up. Following procedure usually stops up some hole or other, sometimes more, so the accident can be avoided.
 
All of these things that are being revealed are heartbreaking because, although not consequential individually, when taken together they added up to the tragedy. However, to me what is even more tragic than the things that NTSB had discovered is that there was one precipitating decision that allowed all of the others to take place. It was fateful and clearly had been taken at some point in the past. I am speaking of the decision to permit helicopter training flights to take place near an extremely busy civilian airport underneath the landing approach path of incoming aircraft. These Army helicopters would be flying across the flight path, directly below descending passenger jets. To me that was a disaster waiting to happen. All it would take would be the right timing and the right combination of circumstances. The result would be inevitable. And it was.
 
Back
Top