What's new
Christian Community Forum

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate fully in the fellowship here, including adding your own topics and posts, as well as connecting with other members through your own private inbox!

Message from Amir Tsarfati update:

1LoverofGod

Well-known
Shalom from Israel! Along with the rest of the world, many in my country celebrated the beginning of a new year. However, instead of the sound of champagne corks and the singing of Auld Lang Syne, we rang in the turn of the calendar to the tune of air attack sirens and the deafening sounds of our low-flying fighter jets. Lest that sound pessimistic, let me tell you that I in no way feel negative about the future of Israel. We are sorrowful, wounded, and heartbroken. But we are not defeated. In fact, it is just the opposite. The Israeli people are filled with a scowling, jaw-clenched determination that should have those who are set on harming us running deeper into their tunnels.

The year 2024 will see Israel at peace and without any more fear of what is just on the other side of its borders.
To get there, though, it is going to take another six-to-nine months. That is what the US administration and the United Nations need to understand. Well, maybe not the UN – they’re hopeless. But the pressure and the restrictions that my government is dealing with from Washington is threatening to hobble the effort. How do people not understand that this is not just an anti-terror action? This is an all-out war against a real enemy.

When the Americans and the British bombed Dresden, Germany, in February 1945, there were no restrictions demanding that the 3,900 tons of explosives be precision directed only at military targets. There was no requirement that humanitarian aid be immediately provided as part of the assault. Instead, it was determined that the reward of shortening the war was worth the cost of the devastation. It was the same thinking used to end the War in the Pacific.

Read complete message here:

 
When the Americans and the British bombed Dresden, Germany, in February 1945, there were no restrictions demanding that the 3,900 tons of explosives be precision directed only at military targets. There was no requirement that humanitarian aid be immediately provided as part of the assault. Instead, it was determined that the reward of shortening the war was worth the cost of the devastation. It was the same thinking used to end the War in the Pacific.

There were no precision weapons back in those days so of course there was no demand for precision. Where they dropped depended on the location of their release and the prevailing winds. It's true that the civilian deaths were considered a reasonable price to pay given the circumstances of the war. Even today things like communications, power, etc. are legitimate military targets so civilians are going to be casualties, especially in an all out war.

In the case of gaza, so many of the residents there are complicit that I don't think Israel should worry overmuch about civilian casualties, but Israel makes a great effort to spare civilians to the extent that it's possible/reasonable.
 
There were no precision weapons back in those days so of course there was no demand for precision. Where they dropped depended on the location of their release and the prevailing winds. It's true that the civilian deaths were considered a reasonable price to pay given the circumstances of the war. Even today things like communications, power, etc. are legitimate military targets so civilians are going to be casualties, especially in an all out war.

In the case of gaza, so many of the residents there are complicit that I don't think Israel should worry overmuch about civilian casualties, but Israel makes a great effort to spare civilians to the extent that it's possible/reasonable.
Israel did what Hamas didn't do.
Before Israel began the defensive strikes on Gaza, they warned the civilians in advance that they were going to strike in a massive way and gave ample time for civilians to get out of the region Before the strikes began.

Hamas just went in there and attacked Israel including civilians and took civilian hostages and tortured and assaulted many of the civilians, without giving anybody a chance to get to safety before attacking.

Israel is being wrongly accused of "genocide" when they gave warning of the pending strikes. There were two stories coming out when IDF started striking Gaza...
That Civilians were not being permitted to leave and Hamas wasn't letting them get to safety.
The other story was that Israel was targeting civilians when it wasn't so.

It's a travesty that the UN says that Israel has "no right to defend themselves."

Every condemnation coming from the UN and world leaders has been against Israel and not one condemnation to Hamas for what they have done and continually attacking Israel and they expect Israel to do nothing while under attack. Preposterous of them.
 
Back
Top