Hi there TCC, I’ve been meaning to ask you about your views on the timing of the rapture. (If you feel like having a conversation about my questions.)
Two specific questions: 1) do you think that maybe the woman in Rev. 12 is the church?, and 2) do you think that the tribulation temple is the millennial temple?
I remember you used to attend John McArthur’s church. I had a friend who got me into following him for a bit. To me he seemed like a regular dispensational kinda guy? I didn’t follow his YouTube stuff that long.
Hi Hol, thanks for asking. I'll go in reverse order. Macarthur is what he called a leaky dispensationalist. Meaning that God has a rejoining plan with Israel the nation, there is a pretrib rapture, and there is a tribulation. Andy Woods believes Macarthur is a leaky covenentalist (not dispensationalist). Covenentalism believes a) Redemption -- Father and Son plan to redeem humanity in eternity past (God gives Son a people, Son redeems, Son gives them back to the Father), b) Adam and Eve were under a works covenant with God, b) covenant of Grace--God provides Messiah. This is sometimes confused as the many different covenants (Noah, Abraham, Moses, David, New Covenant) found in the Bible. Two different things. Below are two links about that if interested. Covenant theology is reformed and in its rawest sense historically would support replacement theology (which Macarthur would not ascribe to).
Dispensational and Covenant Theology - Christ Over All Overview
What is “Covenant Theology” (and should we care)? - Paul Benware Ministries Problems With
Macarthur is a dispensationalist as far as there is a different plan for the nation of Israel. But Macarthur otherwise is a covenentalist. If that makes sense?
2) Temple (tribulation/Millenial) -- I don't know. Most of my life I saw they are two separate things. I suppose they could be the same temple. But there is not that much support on that. I would just say, its possible. I have not studied too much. There is one theory out there by reputable study that sees one in the same. If so it aligned temple build start timing to be on Nissan 10 (Ez 40) by not later than Nissan 10 2025 (factoring in the sabbath year cycles of 49/50 years). This date this year is April 8. I don't expect a temple to be started in April.
3) Rev 12 Woman as Church -- No. Revelation 12:13-14 indicates the woman remains on earth. And is given a safe place in the wilderness during the second half of the tribulation. The women, to me, is Israel during the time AC wants to destroy her. And 12:17 demonstrates I believe end time gentile saints during the tribulation.
I believe the child in Rev 12 is the church. Christ was the head. We are the body. I would see the child going to heaven as the church rapture, while Israel stays on earth. I believe the language of red dragon standing before the woman (12:4) is a picture of Christ (the head) and the church at the time of Ez 38 (the body). So for what looks like a red dragon threat to devour her child, to me, is actually biblical theatrical language disclosing rapture timing (Ez 38). Very multi-dimensional poetic lanaguage I would say. Hope this helps clarify my view on that. Blessings.